Hilsinger first began his work as an entrepreneur more than a decade ago. As previously mentioned, in his earlier years as an entrepreneur, Allan Hilsinger created and expanded several different small businesses. After doing so, Hilsinger then sold those businesses as he kept working as an entrepreneur.

Allan Hilsinger is a member of the Better Business Bureau and Cincinnati USA Regional Chamber. One of the most significant accomplishments Allan Hilsinger has achieved so far in his life is the founding of Guard Well Identity Theft Solutions. Hilsinger founded Guard Well back in 2011 and he currently serves as the company's CEO. Guard Well provides identity management and protection solutions nationwide primarily through the employee benefits space. Guard Well has also won many awards, as well. Allan Hilsinger is frequently cited online and in publications as a subject matter expert dedicated to helping companies protect their employees and their company bottom line from the damages of employee identity theft.